Digital inclusion: Leaving no one behind and no one offline

5 June 2024

Digital inclusion is both a global social goal and a global investment theme, says Eric Opara, analyst in the Sustainable Equity team at Ninety One, and Nikki Gwilliam-Beeharee, Investor Engagement Strategy Lead at World Benchmarking Alliance.

Digital technologies are having a profound impact on individuals and society. These days, most of the world relies on technology for banking, shopping and getting around. As the UN secretary general has said, “a fully interconnected new economy means leaving no one behind – and no one offline”. 1

We believe that digital inclusion is an investible thematic opportunity, and an area where companies have room to improve – which creates an investment opportunity in itself. However, as much as digital inclusion is becoming more widely discussed, there is no clear definition of what it means and how it impacts the world. Here, we highlight some key issues for investors looking to understand the risks and opportunities, as well as use their influence to support digital inclusion.

Not just an EM challenge

Many people think expanding digital inclusion is largely an emerging markets (EM) issue. However, the 2014 UK Government Digital Inclusion Strategy whitepaper highlighted that, even in high-income countries, people are being left behind.2 This was apparent during the pandemic, when many – particularly people on low incomes, small businesses and those in rural communities – struggled to make the transition to life online for reasons of education, cost or access.

Digital inclusion is therefore a global investment theme, but there are stark regional differences. So investors need to tailor their approach for the fact that the challenge of bridging the digital divide often has local characteristics. For example, about 19% of women in developing countries use the internet, vs. 86% in the developed world. 3 Lack of digital access can have the compounding effect of excluding women in EMs from banking and digital communication tools. To combat this, the industry must build networks and work with regional stakeholders to enable internet access at an affordable price.

Artificial Intelligence

Artificial intelligence (AI) has huge potential to make production more efficient. In addition, it could accelerate medical diagnoses and democratise knowledge. But it also poses a significant risk to jobs and, without appropriate safeguards, could widen inequality. There is also a risk that AI could perpetuate biases and discrimination.

For companies that create or use AI, ensuring data privacy and fair use will become all the more important to avoid infringing individuals’ rights and creating unjust outcomes. From an investment perspective, the risks and growth potential of AI need to be monitored carefully at the company and portfolio levels.

Regulation

Digital regulation, which is evolving rapidly, has the potential to have positive or negative impacts on a wide range of companies, and hence investments.

It is becoming increasingly important to establish that companies are putting in place ethical AI principles and frameworks. The key challenge is being able to raise the bar on protections at the same pace at which technology is evolving. Meanwhile, governments will have to strike a balance between providing sufficient oversight and ensuring that regulation does not stifle innovation.

The EU has been on the front foot with AI regulation, with the EU AI Act expected to be ratified this year. We believe this will help to regulate high-risk activities, such as facial recognition technology. It creates guardrails and a penalty if the regulations are not enforced and will accelerate the adoption of regulations globally.

An action-oriented document called ‘Pact for the Future’ will be announced at The Summit of the Future, a UN General Assembly meeting in September.4 This will place reaching a Global Digital Compact alongside existing accords like the Paris Agreement.

The role of corporations

Public markets can offer access to digital inclusion investment opportunities that are best addressed by scale. For example, telecommunications networks use scale to deflate costs, with these savings shared with the consumer, hence making solutions more affordable. When companies adopt a stakeholder approach, ensuring that all voices are heard, it can assist them to create solutions that are inclusive by design.

The role of investors

Investors themselves have a role to play in driving digital inclusion, via their capital allocation decisions and their engagements with companies. Collaborative forums and working groups can allow investors to share expertise and experiences before challenging a company on digital inclusion. For example, via its ethical AI work, the WBA considers what best practice might look like, providing a solid foundation for corporate engagement on governance principles. By using all the tools at their disposal, investors have an opportunity to push digital inclusion forward, whether via stock picking, engagement work or collaborative action.

Conclusion

To us, digital inclusion is about accelerating four key areas: providing access to digital technologies, giving people the skills to use these technologies, mitigating the risks, and making sure any innovation is inclusive and ethical.

We believe companies that contribute to these areas have a substantial growth opportunity, making digital inclusion an investment theme with significant potential. At the same time, investors can play a valuable role in driving digital inclusion worldwide.

1  United Nations, Secretary-General’s video message to the World Internet of Things Convention (10/02/23)

2 GOV UK, Government Digital Inclusion Strategy (04/12/14)

3  ITU, Bridging the gender divide (01/11/23)

4 United Nations, Summit of the Future, Towards a Pact for the Future (2024)

Main image: shubham-dhage-_afH9fjiom0-unsplash