BoE risks financial instability 

12 October 2022

The Bank of England risks financial instability as it looks to balance propping up the gilt market and tightening monetary policy to address rising inflationary pressures, say commentators.

“The Bank of England seems committed to ending its gilt market operations this Friday in an attempt to pivot its policy focus back to tightening monetary conditions. Given the weakness of these markets and huge uncertainty around the government being able to deliver a credible fiscal package later this month, the risk is that volatility will persist and the Bank will be forced to intervene again,” sys Luke Bartholomew, senior economist, abrdn.

“Clearly the Bank is trying to dispel concerns around fiscal dominance, where it would be forced into more permanent operations to support gilt yields in response to the volatility and re-pricing caused by the government’s fiscal policy. While the Bank certainly needs to re-assert its independence and the primacy of its price stability mandate, it is far from clear how credible such statements are given the degree of vulnerability exposed in the gilt market.

“It is a very difficult line to maintain that interventions are currently absolutely necessary to maintain market functioning in a core UK asset market, and that those interventions can only extend until Friday this week and no further. Having to reverse course after such an explicit statement of intent is likely to end up further damaging the Bank’s standing with markets and efficacy of its communication.

Laith Khalaf, head of investment analysis at AJ Bell, says the gilt market is “wobbling” again as the end of the Bank of England’s emergency intervention has been announced and the government’s fiscal plan is still two weeks away. Even that plan may be insufficient to calm bond and currency markets, Khalaf suggests, if it fails to hit the right notes on fiscal discipline.

He adds: “The crisis in pension funds is one of liquidity rather than solvency, but the fear is that if left unchecked, it could leak into other markets, threatening financial stability. Many pension funds clearly think the Bank of England should extend its lifeline, though publicly the governor Andrew Bailey appears to be taking a firm line on the deadline – so far.

“Indeed, the Bank of England is soon planning to start selling gilts on the market, as part of its plans to unwind QE and contain inflation, so it wouldn’t make a great deal of sense for it to be buying bonds at the same time. Yet ultimately it may find itself forced to adjust its plans in order to preserve financial stability, such is the unenviable position the Bank of England now finds itself in.”

UK GDP was reported as contracting by 0.3% m/m in August, compared to consensus expectation of a flat reading, with manufacturing output extremely weak. Q3 output looks set to contract meaningfully, with the Bank Holiday in September also likely to cause a contraction in September’s output too.

“It is increasingly clear that the UK economy is heading into a recession in the near future,” adds Batholomew.