Death benefits within annuities and the tax payable
13 January 2019
The Prudential technical team look at the death benefits that can be provided if a member purchases an annuity contract, and the resulting taxes payable.
These articles are for UK financial advisers and paraplanners only.
Choices and cost
Inclusion of death benefits was a choice the annuitant made at the point the annuity was purchased, and came at a cost. That cost will be reflected in the amount of annuity paid to the annuitant – the more death benefits that are included, the lower the starting annuity will be. That’s because the liability and risk to the annuity provider increases where death benefits are included. So assuming the same purchase price, the amount of annuity that includes provision for a survivor’s annuity will be less than one that does not include such provision.
Where no annuity death benefits are built in to the annuity at the point of purchase, all payments cease on the death of the annuitant, and there is no lump sum or return of capital.
Annuity death benefits that can be included in an annuity fall into a number of main categories:
It is possible to provide both dependant / joint life annuities and guaranteed periods under the same lifetime annuity at the point of purchase.
A guaranteed period is a minimum period of time for which an annuity will be paid, irrespective of how long the individual lives. Previously this guarantee period was limited to 10 years (from the date the annuity was purchased – not from the date of death) but for new annuities bought since April 2015 this is no longer the case.
For example, Bessie chose a lifetime annuity, £8,000 gross a year, paid in monthly instalments, with a guaranteed period of 10 years (even though she may have been able to get a longer guarantee period than this following the legislation changes in 2015). She dies after four years. The guaranteed period means that monthly annuity payments will continue for another six years.
A survivor’s annuity (set up following death) cannot have a guarantee period.
Reference: Section 165(1) ‘Pension rule 2’ and paragraph 3(1)(c) and (2) Schedule 28 FinanceAct 2004)
Joint life annuities
From 6 April 2015 legislation allows new joint life annuities to be passed on to any beneficiary. However, this will impact on the annuity purchase rate and requires the annuity provider to agree to offer this (so allowed for in the annuity terms). However, providers may not be prepared to offer this because of the extra risk involved.
On the death of an annuitant, a joint life annuity will continue to be paid to the survivor for the rest of the survivor’s lifetime – and the survivor doesn’t need to be a dependant. However, the annuity provider may restrict this, say to a named beneficiary. If the member chooses a joint life annuity with, say, a grandchild, the annuity payments are likely to be paid for much longer than if the joint annuitant is in the same age group as the annuitant. So the initial starting annuity would be much lower.
A joint annuity can be paid at any rate up to 100% of the annuity payable to the annuitant. The level that would be paid to the survivor will be set out in the annuity policy terms and, again, is reflected in the cost of buying the annuity.
However, there are a couple of exceptions:
With overlap / without overlap
Where the annuity doesn’t include “with overlap”, the survivor’s annuity won’t start until the end of the guaranteed period if the annuitant dies during the guaranteed period.
Where the annuity includes “with overlap”, the survivor’s annuity will start immediately on the annuitant’s death, even where the annuitant dies during the guaranteed period meaning that:
A joint life annuity is not tested against lifetime allowance when the payments go to the ‘second life’ (that is, not retested on the first annuitant’s death).
Natasha has a level annuity of £15,000 gross pa, payable monthly, including a 10-year guaranteed period and a survivor’s annuity for her husband, Pierre, equal to 50% of the annuity payable to her and set up on a without overlap basis. She dies after six years. The amounts payable will be:
If Natasha had chosen the same annuity but with overlap then Pierre would start to receive £7,500 gross pa immediately, without having to wait four years for it to start. At the same time, £15,000 gross would be payable as the remaining instalments of the guaranteed period – so a total of £22,500 for the four years until the end of the guaranteed period.
Trivial commutation lump sum death benefit
In some cases, the sum left to pay a joint annuitant annuity would provide only a small (trivial) pension income. Where the joint annuity meets a triviality measure on the first annuitant’s death, it’s possible, subject to scheme rules, to pay out the value of the annuity as a lump sum to the survivor.
In this case, the value of the income stream would be actuarially valued, and a lump sum could be paid up to the limit of £30,000 (gross).
Beware the income tax treatment of this type of payment which is covered later.
Reference: Paragraph 20 Schedule 29 Finance Act 2004
The terms of the nominee annuity are agreed at the point the member’s annuity was purchased. This was introduced by pensions flexibility, as long as the member died on or after 3 December 2014 and the nominee becomes entitled to the annuity on or after 6 April 2015. This is where the member can nominate anyone (not limited to a dependant) to receive an ongoing annuity on the death of the member (although this would be subject to agreement by the provider). The difference from joint annuities is that the nominee’s annuity isn’t a continuation of the member’s annuity, but a stand-alone annuity with its own terms and conditions, payable on the death of the member.
An annuity payable to a nominee is a nominee’s annuity if:
(i) it’s purchased together with a lifetime annuity payable to the member and the member becomes entitled to that lifetime annuity on or after 6 April 2015, or
(ii) it’s purchased after the member’s death, the member died on or after 3 December 2014 and the nominee becomes entitled to the annuity on or after 6 April 2015,
(b) it’s payable by an insurance company, and
(c) it’s payable until the nominee’s death or until the earliest of the nominee’s marrying, entering into a civil partnership or dying.
The member would select at the point of purchase if they wanted the annuity to continue to the death of the nominee, or the earliest of the nominee remarrying (or entering a civil partnership) or death.
An uncrystallised funds lump sum death benefit can’t be paid from funds that have been used to purchase a nominee’s annuity.
Reference: Section 167(1) Finance Act 2004 – pension rules 3, 3A and 3B
Paragraphs 17, 27AA and 27FA Schedule 28 and paragraph 3(4A) Schedule 29 Finance Act 2004
Value protection allows a lump sum (after tax if applicable) to be paid on the death of the annuitant. Value protection is available both for scheme pensions and lifetime annuities. The legislative term for value protection is ‘annuity protection lump sum death benefit’ for lifetime annuities and “pensions protection lump sum death benefit’ for scheme pensions, although both generally known as ‘value protection’. Value protection may not be provided in combination with any other death benefit.
The maximum amount (before tax) that can be paid under value protection is:
Annuity purchase price minus the total amount of the annuity payments to date of death (ignoring any tax deducted on the annuity payments).
Derek purchased a value protected annuity with his £100,000 pension fund at retirement. His annuity payment is £5,500 per annum. Unfortunately Derek died five and a half years later. How much will be paid by the annuity provider to his estate following his death?
Purchase price = £100,000
Gross annuity paid to date of death = (£5,500 / 12) x 66 monthly instalments = £30,250
Maximum value protection = £69,750
The lump sum payment is taxed depending on the member’s age when they died – see later.
Reference: Paragraph 16 Schedule 29 Finance Act 2004
In addition to the joint and nominee’s annuities detailed above, there is a third form of annuity which can be paid after the death of a member’s initial beneficiary. This is called a successor’s annuity. A successor’s annuity is purchased from the crystallised funds within a drawdown pension (that is funds not already used to provide a dependant’s or nominee’s annuity). For the avoidance of doubt, a successor’s annuity is not the continuation of a dependant or nominee’s annuity (which both cease on the death of the joint annuitant, or nominee – unless within any guaranteed period attached to the original member’s annuity).
An annuity payable to a successor is a successor’s annuity if:
For the purposes of an arrangement after the beneficiary’s death, the funds within the following are classed as undrawn funds if, immediately before the beneficiary’s death, they were held within:
Taxation of annuity payments
Continued regular annuity payments to a joint annuitant or nominee and payments for the remainder of a guaranteed term, are taxed in line with the tax treatment for drawdown contracts. Since 6 April 2015, the income tax treatment is the same for annuities and drawdown. This is irrespective if they are paid as an income or a lump sum (excluding trivial commutation lump sum death benefit, covered later).
What this means is, from April 2016, the death benefits on annuities are taxed as follows: (click to enlarge)
Reference: Sections 579A to 579D, 646B, 646C and 683 Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003
Where instalments continue under a guaranteed period on the death of the annuitant:
If the capital value of the joint annuity is under £30,000, under trivial commutation lump sum death benefits rules, the benefits can be paid as a lump sum. All triviality payments are taxable in the hands of the recipient. The annuitant’s age at death is irrelevant. The payment of a trivial commutation lump sum death benefit doesn’t have any entitlement to a tax-free element, unlike a trivial commutation benefit paid to a member.
This is only payable in one instance under a lifetime annuity.
If a guaranteed period is specified, any outstanding instalments become payable on the death of the annuitant and form part of the annuitant’s estate for IHT purposes. The person(s) entitled to the money will be determined in accordance with the deceased’s will or the laws of intestacy (whichever is appropriate). This means that the value of those instalments is potentially liable to IHT.
If the payments go to the annuitant’s surviving spouse / civil partner, then no IHT will actually be payable as these transfers are exempt from IHT.
The value of a guaranteed annuity for IHT is not simply the amount of the outstanding instalments. It is the current open market value of those instalments – in effect, what someone would pay now for the income stream up to the end of the remaining guaranteed period.
For example, £15,000 pa is due for another six years under the remaining guaranteed instalments arising on the death of the annuitant. The total of those instalments, over the whole six-year period, is therefore £90,000.
But HMRC allow an actuarial value of the payments due until the end of the guarantee period to be used. For example, the current value of £15,000 pa income for six years might be in the region of say £60,000.
It’s for the executors of the estate to agree with HMRC the value to be included for IHT purposes. To assist, HMRC provides a guaranteed annuity discount calculator. This can be used to provide an indication of the open market value of guaranteed annuity instalments. However, it doesn’t provide calculations for investment-linked annuities – these would need to be calculated individually on a case-by-case basis.
Transfer of dependant’s annuity after benefit crystallisation event
Regulations provide for the transfer of sums / assets by registered pension schemes and insurance companies, where those sums / assets represent pensions in payment.
Where a dependant’s annuity is reduced or stopped due to a transfer of sums / assets and a new dependant’s annuity is not payable in relation to the transferred amounts, the value of the transfer is classed as an unauthorised payment made by the original (rather than receiving) registered pension scheme. The same is true in relation to a dependant’s short-term annuity.
The Registered Pension Schemes (Transfer of Sums and Assets) Regulations 2006/499
Annuity contracts purchased before 6 April 2006
An annuity contract purchased before 6 April 2006 and in payment at that date is not a registered pension scheme. As such, any pension death benefit provided by the contract will reflect the dependency rules in force up to 5 April 2006.
More articles like these can be found on the Prudential Paraplanner Hub