Change in the Fed’s tone not to be taken lightly
13 January 2019
Investors should mark the recent change in the Fed’s tone when communicating the reduction of its balance sheet, says Anthony Rayner, manager of Miton’s multi asset fund range
It would be wrong to say financial markets aren’t always made up of lots of moving parts but it’s also fair to say that the early post-GFC years saw many of these moving parts drowned out by the powerful Quantitative Easing (QE) programmes employed by major central banks.
During the more recent period of QE reversal, led principally by the US, where the Federal Reserve has been reducing its holdings of US Treasuries, there has been a notable increase in the market relevance of some of these moving parts. Taking this one step further, it’s a brave person that argues there is no link between Quantitative Tightening (QT) and the more difficult environment we have seen for financial assets of late.
Taking the macro environment first, the data is increasingly painting a picture of a growth slowdown. For most of last year, many of the manufacturing surveys suggested growth in the major economies outside the US was slowing, but that the US was more resilient. However, the well-regarded ISM US Manufacturing survey recently pulled back sharply from its highs and if we look at the new orders survey, the ‘leading indicator of the leading indicator’, it shows a more prolonged and material decline.
To dispute the slowdown would seem unwise, but to extrapolate it to recession seems premature and unnecessary, as a material slowdown will have enough of a market impact to make it very relevant. The global slowdown has been increasingly priced into markets throughout last year: defensive equity has outperformed economically sensitive equity and US Treasuries have outperformed US corporate bonds. Credit spreads widened materially in the last two months of 2018.
More recently, from a bottom-up perspective, Apple lowered its revenue guidance on weak Chinese sales, adding to concerns about a global slowdown, while the forthcoming fourth quarter earnings season will provide further insight into the health of corporates.
Change in Fed’s tone
Against the backdrop of sharply lower equity markets and broader concerns of a slowdown, there has been a quick change in the Fed’s tone when communicating the reduction of its balance sheet. In December, the Fed’s chair Powell noted the balance sheet was on “auto-pilot”, however this January he shifted to stressing the flexibility in policy, and listening with sensitivity to the messages markets are sending.
While the debate will no doubt rage on as to what these words mean in practice, the Fed is surely right to consider the tightness of financial conditions and their impact on the real economy, as they are right to emphasise that they are flexible in how they react to the data environment. The surprise was the quick change in tone.
Looking more broadly at policy, political leaders are likely to continue to play a dominant role in financial markets with binary outcomes likely, whether it’s Brexit, US-China trade, or the US shutdown. We are trying to ensure we don’t have too much exposure to binary outcomes either way. Across asset classes, we are fairly cautious, with lower than normal exposure to equity and higher than normal exposure to gold. In bonds we remain reluctant to take too much risk whether it’s in credit or duration, and in property we have a small, geographically diversified exposure.
In summary, whether or not we are returning to the old days of bad (macro) news meaning good (policy) news, it is too early to call, or indeed whether Fed policy drowns out most of the other moving parts again. That debate will continue, as will the debate as to whether it will be a soft or hard landing. We value the liquidity of our positions highly so that, in the event of a material change in the data environment, we can react quickly. At first sight, the change in Fed tone is not to be taken lightly.
Readers of Professional Paraplanner will no doubt recall my article on this subject. It contained our top 12 pet...
The assumptions advice firms make when using cashflow models, particularly in planning DB transfers, are widely variable, warns ATEB Consulting’s...
We are delighted to announce the launch of the Professional Paraplanner Awards 2019. This is where you can flag...