Bonds – hurt but not dead

13 May 2024

Are bonds dead? We don’t think so, says George Lagarias, Chief Economist at Mazars.

Patient investors are told that they should wait at least five years before assessing the course of their investment. Since December 2019, just before the pandemic, aggregate fixed income has lost 11% whereas global equities have gained 55%. This is 10.6% per annum for equities and -2.6% for bonds.

Are bonds dead? We don’t think so. At a near 5% yield, and with inflation coming closer to being under control, the real yield is positive. And while the Fed has paused rates for now, eventually it will have to lower rates.

For one, they are currently way above the average natural rate of interest (the one that neither constricts nor stimulates the economy, known as R-Star), which has been estimated just north of 1% by the Federal Bank of New York a few months ago.

Second, high rates are not helpful in a high-debt world, so they are likely to come down and provide some capital appreciation for those already invested.

Negative 5-year bond returns are the result of central bank excesses in the years that preceded 2022, the result of which was a re-rating. Higher yields put a natural cap on how far the rerating can proceed, but full-mean reversion is, at best, a low-probability event.

We are treating bond risk not just as volatility but as a function of downside potential, which is how most people see it.

Going forward, we don’t expect a quick fixed income rebound, but possibly a dragged-out one. It will take years for those who were fully exposed to the 2022 crash to recuperate their losses by being in a simple fixed-income portfolio.

Main image: pawel-czerwinski-6fA05-jKA1M-unsplash